My Thoughts!
Stuart Buxton's "Five Flags: The Warship that Reshaped the Modern World" is a gripping and emotionally resonant account of one ironclad's remarkable journey through the tumultuous 19th century. The history, a mix of naval, global, and nation-building, is done to perfection in the ship that carried five flags during its fairly short life.
Buxton's description is vivid and evocative. He vividly colors the construction of the ship, its bold avoidance of Union blockade, its tempestuous trips across the Atlantic and Pacific, and its crucial involvement in Japan's Meiji Restoration. The narrative is populated with lively characters: opportunist shipbuilders, shrewd diplomats, desperate Confederate operatives, and the cosmopolitan sailors who crewed the Stonewall. The author most effectively captures the political mood of the time and the technology that developed modern naval warfare.
While the book is about the adventures of the Stonewall, it sensibly uses the ship as a lens to view broader trends in the past. We learn of shifting European power balance, the waning power of Spain, and the breathtakingly rapid modernization and militarization of Japan. The narrative brings all the disparate events together seamlessly, explaining how it is possible that one ship could, in effect, symbolize the transfer of global power. The author does not overuse technical jargon, and thus the narrative remains accessible to readers across backgrounds when it comes to naval history.
However, the book is also somewhat superficial in some of its chapters. While the overall story is compelling, there are some historical contexts that could have been described in more detail. Such as the complexities of politics in the Confederacy and Japan could have been explored more so that the reader would have a clearer idea of how the Stonewall impacted those specific contexts.
Beyond this pet peeve, "Five Flags" is an enormously fun and enlightening book. Buxton writes well, having the ability to spin a thrilling yarn that blends adventure, history, and foreign policy nicely. The book is a piece of the often-overlooked role single ships play in the creation of world history and is one whose reading is well worth the time for anyone interested in naval history, 19th-century politics, or the amazing story of Japan's rise to greatness.